xorl %eax, %eax

The 2018 NSA Cyber Exercise (NCX) Module 2 tabletop board game

leave a comment »

Yesterday YouTube suggested me this video from a 2018 event in Maryland, USA by the NSA. It was called NSA Cyber Exercise (NCX) and it had three different modules using the gamification approach. The first was about writing a cyber security policy and was titled Legal & Policy tabletop exercise, the second a tabletop blue/red team exercise called Red versus Blue, and the third a typical CTF game named Live Fire Operation Gongoro Dawn. Due to the pandemic I have some extra spare time so I decided to analyse this video and “reverse engineer” the board game used for the tabletop exercise since it seemed quite nice.

The board game has the red team on the left side and the blue team on the right side. Apart from the two teams, each table also had a third person who is probably the one that keeps track of the score and acts as the guide/narrator and/or observer/judge for the board game. From the video I managed to make a digital copy of the board game which looks like this.

Each square also has some icon representing the equivalent item, but I didn’t want to spend time adding those. Then, you have some decks of cards which are split to the following types of cards.

  • Mapped (Black color)
  • Enumerated (Blue color)
  • Compromised (red color)
  • Bonus (green color)
  • Blue team cards (white back color with NCX logo)
  • Red team cards (white back color with NCX logo)

As you can guess, the black (mapped) cards are placed on top of an item on the board if that item is considered mapped. The same also happens with the blue (enumerated) and red (compromised) cards which are also self-explanatory. Now, the blue and red team cards are different capabilities that each team can take advantage of to execute their strategy. Those cards look like the following where the top part describes the condition, the middle part the capability, and the lower part the impact.

The team cards are pretty simple in terms of their capabilities and it appears that depending on the scenario, the judge/observer is able to provide or take away specific capability cards from the teams. The following capture shows nicely how the teams, judge/observer, and board are placed in the game. On the left side it’s the blue team, in the middle the judge/observer, and on the right it’s the red team.

Although those are kind of self-explanatory too, here are some of the blue team capability cards that were visible in the video. Please note that most of the blue team cards had no condition and their impact was Persistent. Also, note that this is not the complete deck, it’s mostly to give you an idea of what kind of capabilities we are talking about.

  • Security training refresher
  • Internet whitelisting
  • OPSEC review program
  • Rebuild host
  • Password reset policy
  • System log audit
  • Firewall access control updates
  • Conceal server banners
  • Incident response team
  • Patch management program
  • Intrusion detection system
  • Strong passwords
  • Anti-malware controls
  • IP Security (IPSec)
  • Input validation controls
  • Strong encryption
  • Anomaly detection software
  • Web proxy
  • Deploy log server
  • Configuration management review

The red team had many more conditions and variety on the impact. Some of the conditions were things like: Play if the workstations are compromised, Play on mapped only hosts, Play on any compromised host, Play on the internal zone if it is accessible, etc. The same also applies to impact where it is mostly Persistent but some were also Instant. Examples of the red team capability cards you can find here.

  • Ping scan
  • Vulnerability scan
  • Sniffing
  • Reduce operational tempo
  • Port scan
  • Software vulnerability exploit
  • Data injection exploit
  • Pass the hash exploit
  • Cover tracks
  • Cache poisoning exploit
  • Phishing exploit
  • Stolen passwords
  • Cross-Site Scripting (XSS) exploit
  • Broken authentication exploit
  • Server banner grab
  • Build botnet
  • Virus/Worm exploit
  • Open source research
  • Install backdoor and rootkit
  • Zero-Day vulnerability exploit

And of course, there is also a pair of dice which I assume that it was used to determine the result of the proposed action and potentially used for score counting on each round.

Overall it looks like a very nice way for gamification of tabletop exercises for blue/red team engagements and potentially it can be even improved by, for example, using the ATT&CK framework TTPs as red team capabilities and NIST cyber security framework as blue team capabilities. Nevertheless, it is a suggestion with a potential implementation approach based on what NSA did in the 2018 NSA Cyber Exercise (NCX).

Written by xorl

March 28, 2020 at 14:48

Posted in security

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: